Abstract
The authors of other chapters in this volume argue that international economic law is ill-served by excess disciplinary fragmentation. But clearly this dimension of fragmentation exists within the WTO itself as well. To be more specific, the multiplicity of trade regime is not only of interdisciplinary (e.g., IP v. trade, investment v. trade, or climate change v. trade), but also of intradisciplinary (i.e., between different areas of trade law within the WTO regime) discourse. This chapter reviews the negotiations on services emergency safeguard measures (ESM) with a view to offering a critical assessment of the main systematic issues within the WTO - that goods and services are often not subject to common forms of governance. There are many interactions between fragmented regulatory approaches between goods and services worthy of exploration, 1 but in this chapter I will dwell only on the question of to what extent the GATT provisions can be borrowed to establish services ESM. I will take an intradisciplinary approach by analogizing whether and how goods-type safeguards could be adjusted to make it workable in the services context. In doing so, I will take an intradisciplinary focus to examine the issues of normative fragmentation within the WTO. I will argue that in the case the ESM, it is necessary for the GATS to operate as separate and somewhat insular disciplines. Negotiations on ESM under GATS Article X At the time of concluding the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), notwithstanding the existence of a precedent in the goods area, emergency safeguard measures (hereafter ESM) in services could not be agreed since the question of their “feasibility” and “desirability” was not solved. This explains the language used by Article X. Article X:1 of the GATS states that “there shall be multilateral negotiations on the question of emergency safeguard measures based on the principle of nondiscrimination.