Logo image
Higher-order thinking skills in STEM education: A systematic review of HOTS constructs, assessment methods, and chatgpt-assisted coding
期刊文章   開放取用(OA)   同儕審查

Higher-order thinking skills in STEM education: A systematic review of HOTS constructs, assessment methods, and chatgpt-assisted coding

Chih-Hung Wu, Hui-Min Lai, Jun-Kai Wang 和 Yi-Ting Lin
Studies in educational evaluation, 卷.91, 101684
12/2026
Web of Science ID: WOS:001886077200001

摘要

AI-assisted coding Assessment ChatGPT Higher-order thinking skills STEM education Systematic review
Higher-order thinking skills (HOTS) are important learning outcomes in STEM education, but their assessment has not been systematically synthesized. This study reviewed 88 empirical studies published between 2003 and 2025. For the first research question, two human researchers independently coded HOTS-related constructs from assessment instruments and evidence sources, synthesized assessment methods, and examined patterns across STEM domains. For the second research question, we explored ChatGPT’s feasibility on two structured coding tasks: classifying research participants and categorizing research methods. The six most frequently identified HOTS-related constructs were problem solving, analyzing, evaluating, critical thinking, creating, and creativity. Researcher-developed instruments were the most frequently used assessment method, followed by rubric-based performance assessments, validated scales, and qualitative analyses; standardized tests were used less frequently. HOTS emphases varied across STEM domains. ChatGPT supported the preliminary classification of research participants and research methods, but the latter still required human verification. [Display omitted] •This review synthesizes HOTS-related constructs in STEM education.•Problem solving, analyzing, and evaluating were common constructs.•Researcher-developed instruments were the most used assessment method.•HOTS-related emphases varied across STEM domains.•ChatGPT supported structured coding but required human verification.

檔案與連結 (1)

url
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2026.101684檢視
已出版(紀錄版本) 開放

相關連結

指標

1 檢視次數

詳細資料

Logo image