Logo image
英國研究評鑑對教育學門的衝擊:從RAE到REF
Journal article

英國研究評鑑對教育學門的衝擊:從RAE到REF

比較教育半年刊 比較教育半年刊, (76), pp.1-28
2014

Abstract

英國高等教育研究績效評鑑;卓越研究架構;研究評鑑作業;教育研究評鑑;Review of research outcomes in British higher educ;Research excellence framework;Research assessment exercise;Review of education research

Under the belief in the mechanism of marketisation, many government institutions adopt managerialism by using competition for the pursuit of excellence. Britain is one of the forerunners after the ruling of M. Thatcher in 1979. Since the inception of Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) in 1986, it has changed the status of university greatly, from relative autonomy to be under the control of government. The article begins with the motivation of the adoption of RAE which is from managerialism. Individual teacher' s research outputs are evaluated and their total represents the quality of the department. Research fund are distributed also according the outcome of RAE. The differences between RAE and Research Excellence Framework (REF) are also compared. The conclusions of the study are: 1. The review does not includes all types of knowledge in the discipline of education. 2. RAE has caused inappropriate classification of university staffs. 3. University teaching has been neglected, and there is no evaluation for students' learning outcomes. 4. Means becomes end, the spending and operation of RAE is gigantic. 5. Managerialism takes the lead, the ideal of autonomy for university has gone. Although REF2014 has some revisions and added the dimension of 'impact' , it is to be seen whether REF will be more successful than RAE.

Metrics

1 Record Views

Details

Logo image